KLIFEMAP.AI

Wonjinsal · Gwimun-gwansal · Baekhosal · Goegangsal · Gongmang
— why these spirits have no classical basis

First what each one is and how it is worked out — then why the Myeongni classics do not use them.

The conclusion first. Wonjinsal, Gwimun-gwansal, Goegangsal, Baekhosal and Gongmang are folk spirits that the Myeongni classics do not use as grounds for judgement. They are usually grouped together as japsinsal (雜神殺), the miscellaneous spirits.

Our engine does not calculate them. You should still know exactly what they are so that no one can use them on you, so the method for working each one out is set down here.

What the miscellaneous spirits are

A sinsal (神殺) is a name given to a pairing of characters in the chart. Among them, some have a basis in the classics and some multiplied in folk practice.

KindWhich onesBasisWe
The twelve sinsal Jisal · Nyeonsal (Dohwa) · Wolsal · Mangsinsal · Jangseongsal · Banansal · Yeokmasal · Yukhaesal · Hwagaesal · Geopsal · Jaesal · Cheonsal Grounded in the three harmonies (三合) do calculate them
The miscellaneous spirits Wonjinsal · Gwimun-gwansal · Goegangsal · Baekhosal · Gongmang · Cheoneul-gwiin · Hyeonchimsal · Samjae No basis for judgement in the classics do not use them

One by one — what each is and how it is worked out

① Wonjinsal (怨嗔殺)

A folk belief that two zodiac animals hate each other for no reason. It is the thing most often said when compatibility is read, and there is even a phrase for a Wonjinsal couple.

Wonjin pairCharactersHow this pair is arrived at
Rat ↔ Goat子未The Rat clashes with the Horse (午) — the branch next to it is the Goat (未)
Ox ↔ Horse丑午The Ox clashes with the Goat (未) — next to it is the Horse (午)
Tiger ↔ Rooster寅酉The Tiger clashes with the Monkey (申) — next to it is the Rooster (酉)
Rabbit ↔ Monkey卯申The Rabbit clashes with the Rooster (酉) — next to it is the Monkey (申)
Dragon ↔ Pig辰亥The Dragon clashes with the Dog (戌) — next to it is the Pig (亥)
Snake ↔ Dog巳戌The Snake clashes with the Pig (亥) — next to it is the Dog (戌)

The method itself is "one step aside from the clash". The clash (沖) is a concept the classics do use, but taking the branch next to the clash and giving it a separate name is not in the classics.

② Gwimun-gwansal (鬼門關殺)

A folk spirit said to make a person highly strung and nervous. It travels with phrases like having spirit sense or a shaman's chart.

The pairs are handed down as Ja-Yu (子酉), Chuk-O (丑午), In-Mi (寅未), Myo-Sin (卯申), Jin-Hae (辰亥) and Sa-Sul (巳戌). Four of them overlap with Wonjinsal.

⚠ The pairs for Gwimun-gwansal differ between sources. Some use all six above, some only a few. Take the same chart to two places and the answers part ways. That is to say the method was never settled into one.

③ Goegangsal (魁罡殺)

A folk spirit meaning forceful and extreme, applied when the ganji of the day of birth (the day pillar) is one of a set list.

The four usually given are Gyeongjin (庚辰), Gyeongsul (庚戌), Imjin (壬辰) and Imsul (壬戌). Some add Musul (戊戌) and Mujin (戊辰).

④ Baekhosal (白虎殺)

A folk spirit said to bring bloodshed. It too is read from the day-pillar ganji — the seven usually given are Gapjin (甲辰), Eulmi (乙未), Byeongsul (丙戌), Jeongchuk (丁丑), Mujin (戊辰), Imsul (壬戌) and Gyechuk (癸丑).

⚠ Goegangsal and Baekhosal overlap at Imsul (壬戌) and Mujin (戊辰). The same characters are called by two names and given two different meanings.

⑤ Gongmang (空亡)

It means that place is empty, and Dangsaju-style reading takes it as "that area is hollow". Unlike the other miscellaneous spirits, the way Gongmang is worked out is perfectly clear.

The sixty Gapja are made by pairing the ten heavenly stems (Gap to Gye) with the twelve earthly branches (Ja to Hae). Cut into runs of ten, two branches are left without a partner. Those two are that run's Gongmang.

Run (旬)The ten ganji of that runGongmang
Gapja runGapja ~ GyeyuSul · Hae
Gapsul runGapsul ~ GyemiSin · Yu
Gapsin runGapsin ~ GyesaO · Mi
Gapo runGapo ~ GyemyoJin · Sa
Gapjin runGapjin ~ GyechukIn · Myo
Gapin runGapin ~ GyehaeJa · Chuk

The arithmetic is clear, but there is no basis for what it is then said to mean. Two of the twelve branches being left over is arithmetic that follows from the gap between 10 and 12, not a sign that the place is actually empty.

⑥ Hyeonchimsal (懸針殺)

The name comes from characters whose shape is sharp like a needle. Gap (甲), Sin (辛), Myo (卯), O (午) and Sin (申) are the ones usually picked out.

It reads fortune from the shape of a written character. How the sharpness of a stroke connects to what happens in a life is never explained.

So why do the classics not use them

① The method was never settled into one

The pairs for Gwimun-gwansal differ between sources; Goegangsal is four in some places and six in others; Baekhosal is seven in some and eight in others.

Take the same chart to two places and you get two answers. A judgement that changes with the person giving it is not a judgement.

② Whether the structure succeeds outweighs the spirits

The classics are plain about this. If the structure is formed (成格), a chart full of bad spirits takes no harm from them; if the structure is broken (破格), no number of auspicious stars such as Cheoneul-gwiin will help.

What decides the judgement is whether the structure succeeds or fails, not how many spirits are counted.

③ Count the spirits and everyone ends up with a "bad chart"

The list of miscellaneous spirits keeps growing, because any pairing can be given a new name. Make enough of them and everyone has a few.

That is what makes them a good instrument for selling a remedy. It is why "you have a spirit on you" is so often followed by a talisman, a rite, or a spirit-loosening.

Myeongni has no procedure for loosening a spirit. Spirit-loosening and shamanic rites belong to another practice; they are not Myeongni.

Yangin is a different case — not "Yangin-sal" but "Yangin-gyeok"

It is commonly called Yangin-sal, but the classics treat Yangin (羊刃) as one of the structures. Even the name is Yangin-gyeok (羊刃格).

Yangin is the place where the day stem is at its most flourishing, and the classics read it as an inauspicious god (凶神), classing it as a structure used against the grain (逆用) — governed, then used. It sits beside Chilsal-gyeok and Sanggwan-gyeok.

Our engine too judges Yangin-gyeok as a formal structure. Not everything with "sal" in its name is a miscellaneous spirit — the test is whether the classics handle it inside the system.

So what do we use

We calculate only the twelve sinsal, which are grounded in the three harmonies — Jisal, Nyeonsal (Dohwasal), Wolsal, Mangsinsal, Jangseongsal, Banansal, Yeokmasal, Yukhaesal, Hwagaesal, Geopsal, Jaesal and Cheonsal. The detail is set down on the twelve sinsal page.

And the spirits are not the main actors in a judgement. Structure, the useful god and the branch interactions come first; the spirits are laid on top of those.

"Which spirit do I have?" is a less useful question than "Is my structure formed, and what is my useful god?"

Questions people ask

A compatibility reading said we have Wonjinsal — should we separate?

Wonjinsal looks at one zodiac animal from each person and throws away the other six characters. Every couple with the same pair of animals — millions of them — gets the same answer. Our compatibility reading compares all eight characters of both people; you can see it at BaZi compatibility.

Can zodiac-animal compatibility be trusted?

Zodiac compatibility stands in the same place as Wonjinsal. Twelve animals give 144 combinations; eight characters give far more. The animals can match while the other six characters do not, and the other way round. Even if you have been told you have Wonjinsal, nothing is settled until the other six characters are looked at.

Does Gwimun-gwansal mean I have spirit sense?

Some folk readings say so, but there is no basis for it. As set down above, the pairs for Gwimun-gwansal differ between sources. A temperament cannot be settled by something whose method was never fixed.

Will a talisman loosen a spirit?

There is no path by which a Myeongni judgement arrives at a talisman. A talisman appears at no stage of forming the structure or settling the useful god. If the person who gave you the reading immediately sells you something, it is worth asking whether the reading was made in order to sell it.

My day pillar is Goegangsal or Baekhosal — is that a strong fate?

Goegangsal and Baekhosal are names applied from a single ganji, the day of birth. They pick out four or five of the sixty Gapja, so roughly a tenth of the whole population qualifies. It is hard to hold that all those people share one temperament. The two names also overlap at Imsul (壬戌) and Mujin (戊辰) while being given different meanings.

If I have Gongmang, is that place really empty?

Gongmang is arithmetic from the gap between 10 stems and 12 branches. Cut into tens, two are left over — that is all. It does not mean those two are actually empty.

Draw your own Four Pillars chart instead — free

Worth reading next

klifemap.ai